Review Round Up: ‘Jab Tak Hai Jaan’ Woos Critics

Bollywood films, particularly romantic dramas, rarely open to universal acclaim. “Jab Tak Hai Jaan,” or “Until There Is Life,” the last film directed by Bollywood’s “king of romance” Yash Chopra, before he passed away in October, is one of the rare films that did.

Starring Shah Rukh Khan, Katrina Kaif and Anushka Sharma, the romantic drama traces Samar Anand’s (Mr. Khan’s) quest for undying love, from the streets of London to the valleys of Kashmir.

The film, which released alongside “Son of Sardaar” this Diwali, was hailed by many Indian critics. Here’s a roundup of what they had to say:

“There cannot be a better way to portray love on the silver screen,” opined a Zee News review by film critic Ananya Bhattacharya. “Jab Tak Hai Jaan has nailed that – at least for the immediate future.”

Ms. Bhattacharya was all praise for the film’s star cast, particularly Mr. Khan, who in her view brought to life a “newer, better, improved version” of Raj Malhotra, the love-smitten protagonist in Mr. Chopra’s 1995-produced classic “Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge.”

“If as Raj Malhotra he [Mr. Khan] had managed to woo half the population of the country; as Samar Anand, this man can make many more smitten by him. The slight stutter, the little hint of a tear in the eyes, the arms-outstretched pose – Khan knows how to make his ladies fall for him – be it that they are almost half his age!” Ms. Bhattacharya wrote.

The critic went on to applaud Mr. Chopra for his direction. “Only somebody like Yash Chopra could have made those mesmerising locales of Pehalgam and Ladakh come alive on celluloid… The film doesn’t really have the sarees flying slo-mo in the air, but what it has is sheer, pristine beauty,” she wrote.

Overall, Ms. Bhattacharya was highly impressed with the film, though she felt it was “a tad too long” and its background score, composed by Oscar-winning composer A.R. Rahman, had been “underused.”

Nevertheless, she concluded by giving the film four stars out of five. “Yash Chopra, you made sure that you will live on and that your last film will be remembered – jab tak hai jaan,” or until there is life, she wrote.

Jab Tak Hai Jaan “is the best romantic film made in this generation.” That’s how Bollywood critic Rachit Gupta summed up the movie in a Filmfare review.

“Like any piece of commercial cinema, it has its cinematic liberties and plot holes. But the sum of it is an old school love story that weaves its magic on the tender hearts of die-hard romantics,” Mr. Gupta opined.

The critic was all praise for the film’s star cast, its “master class” script and its “real, uncomplicated” dialogue. The film’s plot, though “a run-of-the-mill love triangle” in Mr. Gupta’s view, set itself apart from other romantic dramas, largely owing to its “philosophy, poetic love and honest emotions.”

Jab Tak Hai Jaan “is the perfect adieu to [Mr. Chopra’s] hallmark career,” the reviewer concluded, giving the film four stars out of five.

An NDTV review by Saibal Chatterjee concurred. “Jab Tak Hai Jaan, Yash Chopra’s last film, is a perfectly fitting finale to an eventful life and career.”

The film’s screenplay “is by no means flawless,” but the romantic drama “leaves a soothing afterglow,” Mr. Chatterjee opined.

The critic was also impressed with the film’s theme and character sketches. “Though the focus of Jab Tak Hai Jaan is on the male protagonist, the two women in his life aren’t mere mannequins.” Instead, they are blessed with “grace and intelligence, besides the ability to speak their minds and hold on to their beliefs,” a rare treat in Bollywood romances, he noted.

“Watch Jab Tak Hai Jaan not just for the obvious sentimental reason but for the fact that it shows, for one last time, what Bollywood will miss now that the undisputed master of romantic sagas is no more,” Mr. Chatterjee concluded, giving the film three-and-a-half stars out of five.

“In contemporary times when love stories have more or less turned into instant make out and instant breakup…. it’s heartening to see a full-blown romance saga which has good old values and yet a very modern outlook,” film critic Gaurav Malani wrote in The Times of India.

“Like most love stories, even Jab Tak Hai Jaan has sacrifice and sanctity at its footing yet at no point is it depressing or disheartening,” he added. The critic went on to praise the film’s “impeccable” screenplay, “strikingly beautiful” cinematography and “scrumptious” chemistry between Mr. Khan and Ms. Kaif.

“Jab Tak Hai Jaan is a sublime story about love and life. They don’t make them like that anymore,” Mr. Malani concluded. His verdict? “Very Good.”

Writing for the Hindustan Times, film critic Anupama Chopra was notably disappointed with the film’s plot but on the whole enjoyed the film, largely due to its “heartfelt performances.”

“In any case, you don’t go to a Yash Chopra movie to delve into realism or the messiness of relationships. You go to partake in a fantasy of swooning, idealised love – and Jab Tak Hai Jaan delivers plenty of that,” she noted.

So despite the film’s “wobbly narrative,” Jab Tak Hai Jaan’s “gorgeously shot locations,” “lavish songs,” “inherently noble lead characters,” and “top-notch” star cast performances, makes it work “as an ode to epic romance,” the critic wrote.

Ms. Chopra’s review gave the film three stars out of five.

Tags:
15 Comments
  1. Author
    mate 7 years ago

    So JTHJ become a universally acclaimed film. I don’t see any negative review from the substantial critics apart from our own Baba Ji off-course. 😉
    JTHJ pass one litmus test, hopefully It turns out to be a winner interms of BO performance too.

  2. Ritz 7 years ago

    Red Chillies Ent. ‏@RedChilliesEnt_
    Jab Tak Hai Jaan Reviews: BollyHungama 4/5, ZeeNews 4/5, Filmfare 4/5, BOC 4/5, OneIndia 4/5, NDTV 3.5/5, KoiMoi 3.5/5 – #RetweetThis

  3. Shinji 7 years ago

    “It is hard not to feel upset while watching Jab Tak Hai Jaan, not just because it is the last film directed by the legendary Yash Chopra, but also because the movie borders on cruelty towards us, the paying audience. Packed with characters who all behave well below acceptable human IQ levels, Jab Tak Hai Jaan is a canceled TV soap opera crammed into 3+ hours of banal and lethargic plotting.

    But how can an unbeatable formula that had been set in DDLJ possibly go wrong? It probably won’t, because it will undoubtedly rake in hundreds of crores of rupees. Because in the land of the blind, the one eyed man is the king. And King Khan in Jab Tak Hai Jaan plays Guy Pearce from The Hurt Locker, shifts into Guy Pearce from Memento, hurls one-liners like Guy Pearce in Lockout, and looks like Guy Pearce in Prometheus. Mostly he plays a guy who gives piercing looks to the ladies on a motorbike to the backdrop of the music from Motorcycle Diaries. That’s not to say Shahrukh provides the only unintentional laughs in the film – Anushka Sharma’s entry itself is funny enough to dislocate your lower muscles – the opening shot is the camera lingering on her bum, after which it roves around to her crotch and then firmly affixes itself to her boobs. She then takes a semi naked dive into a lake in Leh, and then screams that the water is too cold. Perhaps she expected centralized heating in Ladakh lakes.”

    http://mihirfadnavis.blogspot.in/2012/11/movie-review-jab-tak-hai-jaan.html

    • Milind 7 years ago

      Fadnavis–a known Aamir loyalist and his reviews have stopped mattering since a long time!

      • Baba Ji 7 years ago

        masand , anupama etc are known to be srk loyalists. but main to bolta hun dont believe anyone . neither masand nor mihir.na utkal na baba na milind. khud picture dekho aur faisla karo. everything is crystal clear.

        • Author
          mate 7 years ago

          Bhaiya, faisla to ho chuka hai. 20 saal main Srk ko pehli baar smooch karte dekhe ge, main to 250 ka ticket 2500 main lene ko tayaar hu. Ek smooch ka sawaal he Baba. 😛

      • Shinji 7 years ago

        hi millind hows ya man? long time

  4. Ritz 7 years ago

    @Sputnik – how can upload a pic here in comment? I dont have posting rights – but if I just want to upload a pic here and give a link to that in comments here – is that possible in WP?

    Btw – ..
    a) what SRK and Redchillies doing on twitter reminds me of what Hrithik did at the time of Kites and Guzaarish.
    b) SOS is trending ahead of JTHJ on twitter – which does not mean anything to me – but just that I am surprised after all the hard work by srk fans on online forums in last 2 months.

    • sputnik 7 years ago

      If the picture is already online somewhere you can use the img tag with src= the link of the image. If it is on your computer then email me at tanqeed@tanqeed.com and I will upload and give you the link.

      I don’t think that red chillies account is official red chillies account.

    • Baba Ji 7 years ago

      agreed .

    • sputnik 7 years ago

      Here is the link – Add the open and close tags in your comment.

  5. Shinji 7 years ago

    Tango Reviews 8.5/10.

  6. saurabh 6 years ago

    The problem is that, when u go nd watch these type of movies with wrong perception,
    u went to jthj with expectation of realism or what, its ur mistake u r expecting something wrong at wrong place..
    have u ever complained dosa wala that bhaiya Chinese Ni hai…
    the problem is that after watching Hollywood movies,u think every movie should be like those..
    i bet if ra one concept is firstly conceptualized by Hollywood, u will think that ohh its possible..(Bt that is because of our indian dependent mentality)
    these type of average movies “jthj, sos” deserves a different kind of perception wen u go to watch these, or otherwise u’ll laugh at serious scene ( jthj), or will feel frustration on comic scene (sos),
    they are average i agree, but jthj certainly don’t deserve a 0 star.. Only a hater can give that..
    u easily said that Chopra nd masand are srk loyalist, u hav any proof, or something, plz be beware of disrespecting somone’s honesty.. U can say these thing abt taran Adarsh as he has given consisting horrible rating, but i guess i cant question anybody else honesty..
    btw good movie is one that don’t dependent on ur perception, like black friday..

Leave a reply

Log in with your credentials

or    

Forgot your details?

Create Account