Manmohan Desai: The Original Entertainer No. 1

Today is Manmohan Desai’s birth anniversary. So check out this Filmfare article with quotes from him.


Manmohan Desai was a genius… He told the audience in the very first frame, `I’m going to make a fool of you’ – Amitabh Bachchan

I was only 24 when I met Manmohan Desai. Just eight years later, this man who was full of joie de vivre, was gone. How? The suddenness of this happy-go-lucky man’s death drove all us movie buffs up the wall. To me, Manji still seems like the least likely candidate for self-annihilation. Though his aching back was against the wall, literally, he held forth on many movies and life with an infectious zest. His comments on offbeat films and film-makers had me in splits. His films were kitsch art, though catch him admitting to anything arty about his works! His cinematic world encompassed a utopia where high melodrama resolved itself magically. To his abiding exasperation, critics insisted on searching for logic in his films. “Do they realise how much brains and money are needed to make my kind of films? I really enjoy what I’m doing… I’m on the sets all the time. I’m not the kind of film-maker who functions from the background. My attitude towards cinema is very serious. I’m involved with every department of film-making except photography. I rarely attend parties. I don’t smoke or drink. My passion in life is film-making. According to critics, if you make anything escapist it isn’t serious cinema. Only gloomy and dull films are serious! But my kind of films require lots of brains.” That was Manji, straight from the hip where he suffered shooting pains. His back was giving him hell. “Someone told me about a chap who cures bad backs with a kick. I’m ready to offer him a lakh for doing this. But if I don’t get cured, I will kick him back,” Manji had chuckled. This was in 1986. Today, he would have offered a crore to have his back cured. If he was still alive.

Amar Akbar Anthony involved my minimum effort, labour and money. It was a fluke hit- Manmohan Desai

The Big IF! If only Manji had lived, David Dhawan wouldn’t have been thrust down our throats with such nagging frequency. When I met him, Manji was worried about the poor collections of his son’s film Toofan. “I’m the monster in Ketan’s life. I’ve already done everything there’s to do with Amitabh. What’s left for Ketan to do?” Ironically, Manji described his best-known collaboration with the Big B, Amar Akbar Anthony as “shit”. He preferred Naseeb, Coolie and even Mard. But his personal favourite was the non- Bachchan starrer Aa Gale Lag Ja. When cynics laughed at the whole concept of Shashi Kapoor impregnating Sharmila Tagore by giving her “body heat,” Manji bellowed back, “What the hell do they mean by escapist films? I make what I like. I love Mother India. Every time I see it, I get an inferiority complex.” Ignoring the sniggers he did the `body heat’ act again in his last directorial venture Ganga Jamuna Saraswathi with Mr Bachchan and Meenakshi Seshadri. To drive the point home, he even showed us a cobweb while the lead pair gave each other garmi in a barn. He defended every film of his like a lion protecting his cubs. He admitted the lost-and-found formula began with Kismet in 1943 and that it was a convenient peg to hang his ideas.

After Shamshad Begum sang Kajra mohabbatwala, for Biswajeet, she never sang again for a Hindi film

His favourite actors were Raj Kapoor, Nutan, Lalita Pawar, Nirupa Roy and of course Amitabh Bachchan. For his first film Chhalia in 1960 he signed Raj Kapoor and Nutan. Then followed the ill- fated Bluff Master and Budtameez. Both Shammi Kapoor-starrers bombed miserably. His harvest of hits started with the espionage thriller Kismat in 1968. For the first time a leading man (Biswajeet) did a drag-act in Kismat. After Shamshad Begum sang Kajra mohabbatwala, for Biswajeet she never sang again for a Hindi film. Sachcha Jhooth in 1971 won Rajesh Khanna his first Filmfare award. The next year Manji had three releases, Bhai Ho To Aisa, Rampur Ka Lakshman and Sharaarat. The first two were hits. Roti in 1974 was one of Rajesh Khanna’s last major successes as a leading man. 1977 was a watershed year for Manji. Four of his big budget spectacles–Amar Akbar Anthony, Chacha Bhatija, Parvarish and Dharm-Veer–were blockbusters during this year. Said Manji, “Amar Akbar Anthony involved my minimum effort, labour and money. It was a fluke hit. When it was released, I thought it had good songs. But I never thought it would be such a success. I was sure Aa Gale Lag Jaa would be a superhit while Amar Akbar Anthony would flop.” Naseeb in 1981 was Manji’s most expensive film, followed by Suhaag and Desh Premee. In 1983, during Coolie, when the Big B suffered his near-fatal accident, Manji had to give in to popular sentiments and let his hero live at the end. “Audiences would have been very disappointed if after the accident Amitabh was shown dying at the end of Coolie,” confessed the emotional film- maker.

I ‘m the monster in Ketan’s life. I’ve already done everything there’s to do with Amitabh. What’s left for Ketan? – Manmohan Desai

After Mard in 1985 and Ganga Jamuna Saraswathi in 1988, Manji retired from movie-making. Those close to him say he had secretly become depressed in his final days. The plot for Amar Akbar Anthony was inspired by a newspaper report about a man who left all his three children at different places and then committed suicide. “What if the man didn’t kill himself?!” Manji wondered. And we wonder the same about him. The Big B who was so close to him once said, “Manmohan Desai was the genius who had the audacity to tell the audience in the very first frame, `I’m going to make a fool of you. I’m going to be illogical and you had better enjoy it’. Magically the audience did. He had no pretensions. The audience knew he believed in the improbable and went along with him. They just loved him.” Just think. If Amitabh Bachchan and Govinda were brought together by Manmohan Desai, the movie moghul would have been a crorepati many times over, ‘chappar phaad ke’.

If only Manji had lived, David Dhawan wouldn’t have been thrust down our throats with such nagging frequency


  1. Baba Ji 11 years ago

    “His favourite actors were Raj Kapoor, Nutan, Lalita Pawar, Nirupa Roy and of course Amitabh Bachchan”

    all overactors including even amitabh in his films.

  2. Baba Ji 11 years ago

    “Ironically, Manji described his best-known collaboration with the Big B, Amar Akbar Anthony as “shit””

    that says it all

    • Author
      sputnik 11 years ago

      LOL I never liked Amar Akbar Anthony. Good that Manmohan Desai himself hated it. Not a fan of Naseeb, Coolie, Mard either.

      • Baba Ji 11 years ago

        he was the father of crap masala films. bollywood has preserved that tradition to date

  3. dwnpiyush 11 years ago

    I have never been able to complete Mard/Coolie/GJS. Love Amar Akbar Anthony and must have seen it more than 10 times on TV. Naseeb was more or less a derivative of AAA, and didn’t really enjoy it. Till recently thought Shaan to be directed by him, and I would have termed it my favorite Manmohan Desai film, had it been the case. Get confused between Suhaag and Parvarish, though both are quite entertaining. Have seen his two Dharmendra films, Dharam Veer and Chacha Bhatija, in installments on TV and can see why they must have been the huge hits they were. Coudn’t sit through Roti when it was being aired on MAX recently. Haven’t seen any of his earlier films.

    • Author
      sputnik 11 years ago

      Agree with you that Naseeb was more or less a derivative of AAA. Saw one hour of Suhaag on DD once in the 90s and did not like it. Have not seen Parvarish, Roti and GJS.

      Saw Dharam Veer as a kid and did not mind it back then. Dharmendra was dressed like Romans/Greeks. Liked Rampur Ka Laxman and Aa Gale Lag Jaa when I saw in early 90s.

      • dwnpiyush 11 years ago

        Never dared to see Rampur Ka Laxman as I am allergic to Randhir Kapoor.

        • Author
          sputnik 11 years ago

          Don’t like Randhir Kapoor either but those were the days when I used to watch every movie that came on DD Metro on Saturday afternoons 😉

  4. Shalu Dhyani 11 years ago

    Can’t believe he called AAA shit 🙁 It is one of my all time favourite films, I have seen it more than 30 times.

  5. hithere 11 years ago

    @9:00 he talks about AAA. I don’t think he would talk fondly about a “shit” movie.

    • Baba Ji 11 years ago

      it is said that success is like fart. sirf tabhi bardaasht hoti hai jab khudki ho. its understandable.

    • Author
      sputnik 11 years ago

      hmm well can’t be sure if Manmohan Desai actually said that coz the Interviewer is Subhash K Jha 😉

      But you never know people might change their opinions of their own movies. Karan Johar accepted that KKHH, K3G and KANK were bad and MNIK had horrible Hurricane climax recently while he never admitted to that back when those movies released.

  6. hithere 11 years ago

  7. hithere 11 years ago

  8. ank_16n 11 years ago

    For me Amar Akbar Anthony was Brilliant , Awesome, Superb….

    Mard was over the Top but liked only last 45 min of the movie..!!

    Sachaa Jhutha was just one of my best films that RK ever worked so it was a very good…good movie..!!

    Raampur Ka Lakshman —was one one Randhir kapoor best movie had watched it last some 3-4 years back but its still very much fresh in my memory..!!

    Dharam Veer —bakwaas except the 1st 30 min of movie..!!

    Chacha Bhatija —very good movie Dharm paaji and Randhir kapoor rocked specially after they entered as Naukar in their own house..!!

    Parvarish —-again liked it very much…..had watched it some 10 times if not more..!!

    Suhaag —–ok…ok movie Time pass..!!

    Naseeb —-Total shit of a movie..!!

    Coolie —didn’t liked the last 1 hr…rest movie is good..!!

    Gangaa Jamunaa Saraswathi —maybe the worst Amitabh and Manji movie..!!

  9. ank_16n 11 years ago

    oh…forgot to mention ROTI…..
    just awesome movie…

    Gore mukhde pe itna gumaar na kar gora rang pal do pal mein dhal jayega..!! 🙂

  10. Serenzy 11 years ago

    I Have Watched Only AAA by Manmohan Desai and I Totally Looooove that Movie.

    Easily, One of the Wholesomest Entertainers Ever Made in B’Wood and the Movie has a High Repeat Value for Me!

    I Love Rishi-Neetu Jodi, Bachchan, Parveen Babi[SexY!], Nirupa Roy, Pran and Jeevan in AAA.

    And it is Nicely Directed with Some Zabardast Scenes after Scenes[Fantastic Story/Screenplay].!!!

    I like the Songs too[Parda hain Parda, Tayyab Ali, Title Track, Humko Tumse ho gaya hain Pyaar kya Karien, My Name is Anthony Gonsalves ]

    The Way Manji has Based that ‘Lost and Reunited/Revenge’ Theme within the
    3 Religions is a Masterstroke.

    Amar Akbar Anthony – BEYOND RATING

  11. ank_16n 11 years ago

    @Serenzy —vinod khanna ko bhool gaye…..kya woh pasand nhi aaye..!!

  12. Serenzy 11 years ago

    Vinod was Good too but Compared to what all I have Mentioned, Vinod-Shabana Azmi Pale in Comparison.

Leave a reply

Log in with your credentials

Forgot your details?