Ishq Shava Song – Jab Tak Hai Jaan

90 Comments
  1. Author
    aryan 7 years ago

    Excellent song everything is perfect in this song.

  2. sputnik 7 years ago

    Song sounds great with the video. Katrina is looking hot and dancing well too. SRK seems to be low on energy in some scenes but good in some scenes.

    • hithere 7 years ago

      I still prefer the Pink skirt of SIK 😉

      • Baba Ji 7 years ago

        why? she was wearing longer shorts under the pink skirt. 😛 this is shorter

        • hithere 7 years ago

          I thought you would comment one the “slide” than length of the shorts 🙂

          • Baba Ji 7 years ago

            I had already commented on the slide in the teaser that came few days ago.srk wanted to see what katrina is wearing underneath.

      • Ritz 7 years ago

        Yes, she was lively in the SIK songs than this. Here look at her steps in the beginning 0:10 to 0:16 – absolutely nothing in the choreography …also later in the song what srk and cat do with a plastic bottle looks so lame. and wannabe.

        The camerawork is very good though and that creates an impression that choreography is good.

        • Ritz 7 years ago

          I repeat

          The camerawork is very good though and that creates an impression that choreography is good.

          Saw the song again and choreography is really really bad. But camerawork is too good.

      • Ritz 7 years ago

        I think her dance steps were more lively in that SIK song. The dance steps here do not even qualify as dance steps …she is is hardly moving.

  3. mate 7 years ago

    Yes, Srk can do better than that, as he hardly had any ‘moves’. It seems the choreographer deliberately give good steps and focus more on Katrina.

  4. mate 7 years ago

    But must say the overall impact of song+video is really good.

  5. Aditya007 7 years ago

    Dont like Much !
    choreography Seems good but lyrics not upto Mark as movie comprise the name of Gulzar+Rahman Combo!

  6. Baba Ji 7 years ago

    lame song and even lamer choreography. the song was anyway not catchy and so some violent dance steps were needed. katrina is hardly moving bcos of the fear of may be what she is wearing.srk could never dance so its no surprise. now the reason for katrinas skimpy clothes in this song looks reasonable.there is nothing else in the song.

    • sputnik 7 years ago

      SRK is or was a good dancer. He has always danced well whether it is Yeh Kaali Kaali Aankhen or Chand Taare or Love Mera Hit Hit. He always had energy and a certain grace and that’s important in dance. Don’t care for aerobics or stupid gymnastics in dancing. Bollywood has not used him well in dancing.

      Prabhu Deva and Hrithik are among the best and in another league. Never liked Shahid’s dancing. He does the same dance moves in every song and still dances like the back up dancer he was before.

      • Baba Ji 7 years ago

        srk has been an average dancer always.i ddint find him better than salman in the 90s.aamir is worst dancer among the khans.

        aerobics and gymnastics are not dances.aerobics are a form of physical exercise while gymnastics is a sport.however some moves in them are visually so good and difficult to do that they became a part of modern dance.Today dance is a fusion of various art forms. The most famous form of dancing, B-Boying itself has taken most steps from Capoeira, a martial art,not a dance.

  7. mate 7 years ago

    True, Srk is a bad dancer as per today’s standard, and the age-factor may also be the reason for his lame steps. And Hrithik, Shahid or a Jacky Bhagnani can do much much better than Srk. I totally agree wid you Sir.

  8. mate 7 years ago

    Yes, I also think Salman is the best dancer amongst the Khans and Aamir be the worst. I am not talking about aerobics or gymnastics, but even for usual and simple stuff, he had never been perfect, or say, never intended to do that. I can’t imagine Srk to do the dancing moves, made by Salman in Wanted. I can give you an example, he was almost perfect in Love Mera Hit, agreed, because those steps were in his comfort-zone, but in a song like Dance Pe Chance, his moves were faulty, I don’t know whether he did’nt rehearse it properly or those were outside his range and same is the case here. ‘Criminal’ is also be considered as his finest, but in Chammak Challo he again struggled with his moves.

  9. mate 7 years ago

    But one thing is for sure, He is not as bad a dancer as Salman as an actor. Actually he is more than an average dancer.

  10. mate 7 years ago

    what’s is that video, Baba Ji. Sorry, It does’nt work here.

  11. Suprabh 7 years ago

    Is this actually Gulzaar-Rahman-Yash combo? this is more like Saleem Suleman-Sameer-David Dhawan combo.

    And what hell does ishq shava means? They are not calling it shaava (like shaava oye hoye from DDLJ -mehndi saja ke rakhne)..Does it mean Shaving up your Ishq?

    Srk looks exhausted…as if needs CPR –he should listen to..#cpr song Teri saans se saans nikli toh mujhe saans aayi

    • Milind 7 years ago

      “And what hell does ishq shava means? They are not calling it shaava (like shaava oye hoye from DDLJ -mehndi saja ke rakhne)..Does it mean Shaving up your Ishq?”

      And then such highly smart folks claim that they do understand lyrics of Gulzar and can term it pedestrian.

      A person is confusing between “Shava” and “Shaava” and is trying to be smart.

      Shava means cure/ilaaz and Shaava means a term for celebration.

      Are you sure you have heard Gulzaar ever? I dont think so. Critising without appreciating lyrics is as big a crime as to like Akki in hiding.

      • Suprabh 7 years ago

        Milind,

        It would be better if you stick to the topic….If you dare to be personal, I wont even take a second to leave this forum..I am only here because Sputnik said this is strictly not allowed here.

        • Milind 7 years ago

          Where have I gone personal? I called you smart. I called you an akki fan in hiding. That is all. What was personal in that. Dnt know being called an akki fan is so shameful even after RR and OMG!
          And don’t express your anger of being ignorant abou Urdu language on me. Had your intentions been right,you wouldnt have mocked..you would have asked. Shava..shave..wth!!

          • Baba Ji 7 years ago

            even i think OMG is the best film of the year.it doesnt make me akshay fan.

          • Milind 7 years ago

            Where have I said liking OMG makes you an akki fan? I dont even know if Suprabh liked OMG! I said there is no shame now to get your name attached to Akki after RR and OMG. Babaji..dimaag kitthe hai? :p

          • hithere 7 years ago

            “even i think OMG is the best film of the year.it doesnt make me akshay fan.”
            OMG was Paresh’s movie. Akshay had a sizable role but if that role was done by say Anupam Kher it would have been dubbed as character role.

          • Baba Ji 7 years ago

            ofc OMG is paresh’s movie. I was replying to milind who thinks liking OMG is like subscribing to akshay.

        • Ritz 7 years ago

          I was desperate to be on other forum and I am on this forum only because of ppl like sputnik and U suprabh.

          I know i dont have a choice, as the other forum had abandoned me, I didnt had any choice…

          I was trying not to get addicted to this forum like I was to NG …but I think Sputnik knows me better than myself as he didnt give me posting rights 🙂

          I agree with u Suprabh, and sad to see you also leaving this forum.

          I know I have no choice, but I also wont comment more henceforth…(Sorry Sputnik but cant help)

          🙂

          Love u all

          /Ritz

          • Ritz 7 years ago

            ……..Cant help when u trust other “nuisance makers” more as good “contributors” to a site. just because of their writing and not because of interaction with others…

            Just a question Sputnik – are you a individual prgrammer or a people manager in real life? …pls dont mind…

      • sputnik 7 years ago

        Milind,

        You can make the same point without remarking on the person’s smartness or lack of it and bring in some other star.

        —————————

        I also thought it meant Shaava and that Rahman had the singer sing it as shava for effect.

        Anyways this is what I found

        “Going by that, Shavaa would mean a cure, a recovery, and so the lines Ishq Shavaa, Mushq Shavaa, Khushamadeed-e-Marhaba would mean ‘Love is cure, fragrance is cure, Welcome (them), welcome (them)’.

        Basically the meaning here is that contrary to the proverb ‘Ishq aur mushq chhupaye nahi chhupte’, which means Love and Fragrance cannot be hidden, the poet here says that we should welcome, enjoy and rejoice love and fragrances, say, instead of even trying to hide them.”

        http://www.bollymeaning.com/2012/10/ishq-shava-meaning.html

        • Milind 7 years ago

          Ok.Sputnik.Advice Taken. 😀

          Don’t tell me you didn’t like my comment and clarification of shava and shaava. 😀

          • sputnik 7 years ago

            I already said you could have just given the clarification.

        • Baba Ji 7 years ago

          lyrcis are still not proper.love is not a cure.lust is cure IMO. ppl need sex just like food,water etc.its need of body.its a necessity.not love.

      • Dhamaka 7 years ago

        bhai who says shava means cure/ilaaj ?
        I am a pure urdu speaking person and never heard this word….. In urdu cure/ilaaj means Shifa/ Shafa (some people wrongly pronounce shifa as shafa) not Shava even the urdu translation of Hospital is DAR-UL-SHIFA
        I my opinion Gulzar sahab used this word as poetic liberty to get the better rhyming

        • Baba Ji 7 years ago

          thanks for this piece of information.

          “I my opinion Gulzar sahab used this word as poetic liberty to get the better rhyming”

          if that is the reason,then gulzar is a stupid man.

        • Milind 7 years ago

          Bhai agreed u more versed with urdu. Are you versed with Urdu vernacular?

          Have you seen Lallan Miyaan who runs a pan shop at nukkad of saahebganj meet bhola doodhwaala and on seeing him ill,he remarks— ” Dawa-Shava kyun nai lete”.

          Had you been versed with Gulzaar you would have also been versed how often he inserts the vernacular Urdu rather than khaalis Urdu. He also experiments with Khaalis Urdu but not now much.

          Please think on it!

          • Dhamaka 7 years ago

            Have you seen Lallan Miyaan who runs a pan shop at nukkad of saahebganj meet bhola doodhwaala and on seeing him ill,he remarks— ” Dawa-Shava kyun nai lete”.

            i think you have’nt read my last line that he might use this word as a poetic liberty other wise even bhola doodhwala or lallan miyan bhi shava as a single word use nahin kerte 🙂 because shava has no meanings as per my knowledge people just use it like OK SHOKAY

            warna aap tu doctor ho kal se patients to Dawa ki jagah Shava dena start ker dain 😀

          • Milind 7 years ago

            Actually we both are on same page–i am talking about vernacular Urdu– Gulzaar takes a lot from it… and yes liberty li hai thodi par meaning waisa hi rehta hai.

          • Milind 7 years ago

            in any case it is not the punjaabi “shaava”…uski pronounciation hi doosri hoti hai

          • Dhamaka 7 years ago

            yes you are right gulzar takes alot from vernacular urdu …who can forget his chappa chappa charkha chale ouni bouny yaariyaan teri ouni bouny bairiyon tale 🙂 ……….
            i just listen the song properly and he indeed use this shava word to get the write balance with the words like MARHABA , LAGA ,ZARA etc

            well on topic i like the song and picturisation is really good

      • Ritz 7 years ago

        Milind, I also haven’t heard a word called Shava in Urdu. I contacted some urdu experts on this and they said the same thing.

        I believe Gulzar has used it only for rhyming…in the song.

  12. mate 7 years ago

    Sir, you can say these steps lame/exhaustive or whatever, as it involves Srk, but plz don’t criticize Rahman music without any reason. I hardly listen such innovative yet addictive composition by any composer (in bollywood), that’s the Rahman magic. Though the whole album is below his standard, but still the best of the year so far by margin. And Challa song is perhaps the best of the past few years penned by any lyricist.

    • Milind 7 years ago

      what lame statement you just made that if it involves SRK,one may call it whatever!! Did I get you correctly mate!

  13. Serenzy 7 years ago

    This is The BEST Song of JTHJ both Audio & Video Wise.
    Apart from this, I Only Liked Heer and Challa.

    ‘Jiya Re’ Video is Good[Anushka’s Energy + SRK in Pink 😛 ] but Not the Song.

    JTHJ Title Song and Saans is Bad…Pathetic!

  14. mate 7 years ago

    Milind, though i am a fan of srk acting, I try to be as impartial as i can.

  15. Suprabh 7 years ago

    Okay..thats it for me…

    Sputnik, Its not a threat or a request…I am just letting you know about what I said when I joined the forum..I know this guy is the biggest reason..any forum can go down…And you may want to be away from such people.

    I cannot comment in an environment where people like him keep getting personal everytime someone mocks their fav star…You can search tanqeed or NG to find I have mocked every actor as much…at times maybe even more.

    but this guy is beyond all this talk and he will keep throwing statements like “okay point taken..etc etc”..when in reality he wont ever get the point…I would prefer to be off this forum as long as he is here.

    Regarding shava and my limited knowledge of urdu..I have been speaking hindi/urdu all my life and I haven’t come across that word..and No I don’t think it means cure..that website link also mentions that they are just guessing.

    Peace out.. best wishes..and good luck with tanqeed.

    • Milind 7 years ago

      “I cannot comment in an environment where people like him keep getting personal everytime someone mocks their fav star…You can search tanqeed or NG to find I have mocked every actor as much…at times maybe even more.

      but this guy is beyond all this talk and he will keep throwing statements like “okay point taken..etc etc”..when in reality he wont ever get the point…I would prefer to be off this forum as long as he is here.”

      You don’t need to leave.I anyways had distanced myself when I saw you here. But then TQ has been a site close to heart.So come here. But before I leave,let me just say…wasn’t this the same thing I used to tell once upon a time somewhere and you used to laugh and mock.Just made you remember.Not necessary I am after you for the same reason, Strange that it comes from your mouth. But wonders happen in this world.

      “I am just letting you know about what I said when I joined the forum..I know this guy is the biggest reason..any forum can go down…And you may want to be away from such people.”

      The man who destroyed Ng single-handedly is saying this. Great. Welcome.But TQ is a diff place nad I wont mention NG as a baggage of past. The man who played dirty politics is saying this.But I accept you are an honourable man. Yes Sputnik needs to be away from me,.Thus I am away from this forum since I see double faced men like you. I am the reason why NG went down…woaahhhhhh..big statement from the man whom the world believes in having a hand in bringing it down.

      Sputnik,

      I was associated with you since long ago.I am still with you. But you just saw the snide remarks at me.Don’t worry I wont comment here. Your forum peace shall not be disturbed. But someone saying such filthy remarks inspite of having a black heart is not what TQ practiced.

      Love

      • sputnik 7 years ago

        Milind,

        Don’t leave. Forget all the past history or petty wars. You are great at writing original articles and you should not waste your talent.

        You need to have a offline conversation with suprabh and you both need to sort out whatever issues you have with each other. Or else just ignore each other here.

        • Ritz 7 years ago

          hmmm………..

          LOL ..

          😛

          • Milind 7 years ago

            ROFL! To see who is speaking about interaction within the site! history is associated with all.Let you not fool us Ritz. You associated yourself with this forum just coz you were thrown out of NG. Otherwise when you were on NG..you used to continuously make fun of TQ and calling it a site for srk fans who left Ng and what not.No saintly gestures here bhaisaahab.

            Anyways..stop this blackmailing affair.

    • sputnik 7 years ago

      suprabh,

      Don’t leave. I had edited Milind’s second comment and also warned him not to keep bringing in personal remarks or some other star. I will edit or delete his comments if he tries to get personal with you again.

      I have also been speaking Hindi/Urdu all my life but when it comes to Gulzar I don’t know many words that he uses. I know that the site is probably guessing but until Gulzar issues a explanation or someone well versed gives an explanation we cannot be sure.

      A few days back hithere posted a Gulzar song from Ghulami – “Zihaal-e-miskin” and I did not know what it meant or that the first two lines were reworked from a Amir Khusrao poem.

      http://sufipoetry.wordpress.com/2009/11/06/zehaal-e-miskeen-amir-khusro/

      https://youtube.com/watch?v=8UC7QWELzCY

  16. mate 7 years ago

    Suprabh Ji, dont leave plz. I find this forum the best atleast much better than NG that is totally hijacked by a sadak-chap mafia and rikshah drivers union, often disclosing their family background and discussing their extra marital affairs on the blog. I hardly seen any hot discussion here over an issue, forget about abuses or any foul language. Opinions may differ and we cant force each other to change our POV. Like Baba Ji find OMG the best movie of the year, while according to me, it’s just another mindless comedy. Yes it has a social message, that make it loveable for most, but not for me. Sorry Baba ji for differing from u. 😛

    • Milind 7 years ago

      “I find this forum the best atleast much better than NG that is totally hijacked by a sadak-chap mafia and rikshah drivers union, often disclosing their family background and discussing their extra marital affairs on the blog. I hardly seen any hot discussion here over an issue, forget about abuses or any foul language”

      This attribute of Ng today is largely due to the man whom you asking to stop!

      Karma is a bitch! It pays back. I loved it.

      All of you njoy here. Yes I can proudly say I was one of the initial members and I never advised Sputnik to be away from Suprabh. I dont give idiotic advises.

  17. mate 7 years ago

    Milind Ji, ap to TQ ka keemti sarmaya hain, iss forum ko ap jese bakamaal logo ki ashad zuroorat hai. So I request you too, to stay here.

  18. FS 7 years ago

    Best song and video so far. except 2-3 close ups srk is looking good and kat as always fab.

  19. mate 7 years ago

    I am quite sure that the shava is taken from Punjabi, not that it is an actual word of punjabi but used to represent a kind of celebration. But we can’t say that ‘Ishq shava’ means ‘celebration of ishq’ but ‘shava’ here is used as an independent word and used in that context.

  20. mate 7 years ago

    Sputnik sir, may i know what’s the criteria of getting posting rights here. And one more thing why the comments are not sort by date, or is that happening only with me. BTW
    Wish a very Happy Eid-ul-azha to all the TQers. EID MUBARAK.

    • sputnik 7 years ago

      “Sir bahut shareef sa lagta hai” call me sputnik 😉

      What do you want to post? And do I know you from another forum?

      Are you talking about comments on the sidebar or on the post?

  21. mate 7 years ago

    Right now I have no such article and neither I am very keen to post, but just for information, like If i want to post any article/video/news, what should I do.
    I am talking about the comments appeared below the post. Like this is likely to be 57th comment posted by me, and after sometime I found the number of comments will exceed to 59, but my comment still show at the last, and i have to search for the later 2 comments in between.
    No you dont know me, but I keep visiting SS and NG blog for long time, and be familiar with almost all the members’ writing style. And I have been a regular visitor and fond of TQ from the very beginning.

    • sputnik 7 years ago

      Have you registered on the forum? I don’t see you as a registered user. Register using the link on the top right corner and I will give you posting rights.

      If someone replies to 50th comment using the Reply link below it then that comment will appear under the 50th comment. Otherwise it will show up below your comment.

  22. mate 7 years ago

    Ok Done. Thanks a lot Sputnik ji. 😀

  23. sputnik 7 years ago

    “Jab Tak Hai Jaan” premiere being held in accordance with Yashji’s wishes on Nov 12th

    In accordance with Yash Chopra’s wishes, his wife Pam Chopra has decided that a grand film premiere be held to celebrate the release of Yashji’s JAB TAK HAI JAAN this Diwali.

    “I want to give my husband an unforgettable farewell. Accordingly, we have decided to have a grand premiere for his ultimate film, JAB TAK HAI JAAN, exactly the way he wanted it. This is a fitting tribute to a man who would have had it no other way. I have asked my sons Aditya and Uday to go ahead with all the preparations. This premiere is our way of celebrating his illustrious life, rather than mourning it”, said Pam Chopra.

    Consequently, a premiere is being planned by YRF on 12th Nov 2012, details of which are being worked out.

    http://www.yashrajfilms.com/News/NewsDetails.aspx?NewsID=8cc458dc-a613-47bc-9b17-040bda66f93a

  24. Serenzy 7 years ago

    “that is totally hijacked by a
    sadak-chap mafia and rikshah
    drivers union, often disclosing their family background and
    discussing their extra marital
    affairs on the blog.”

    😀

  25. Aditya007 7 years ago

    @hithere Ji ,Kiske Fan ho? Just tell me.
    OMG was Akki’s movie [As a actor ,producer & some good promotion ].
    If its not then you’ve seen VD /kahani trending is approx same as OMG but collection will be arounf 85+cr .So You can understand ,when people know akki present there in movie [in 1st promo there was only paresh showing,so people thinks its only paresh’s movie ,but wont] they will going for It,after it you can seen how did collection increased day by day.
    & who says its a mindless comedy, then He should retire from this world.RIP his brain for mindless inings.

  26. sputnik 7 years ago

    @Ritz,

    “……..Cant help when u trust other “nuisance makers” more as good “contributors” to a site. just because of their writing and not because of interaction with others…”

    Some people also advised me not to have you here 😉 but I feel you are a “good contributor” with your music related comments.

    I always liked Milind’s writing skills when it came to his articles but was never a fan of his comments when he was indulging in petty wars. I laid out the rules at the beginning and Milind has not commented like he used to do on NG. Whenever his comment has become a little personal or provocative (a few times) I have stepped in and edited his comments or warned him.

    Milind can at least write great articles but there are some on another forum who always make provocative or nonsense posts with an agenda for/against a particular star, indulge in abusing stars or other star fans and yet people never say we are leaving this forum now.

    I will say this to you and everyone else – go to the other forum read the posts and comments there and compare them with the posts and comments here and decide for themselves which is better.

    • Baba Ji 7 years ago

      excellent comment sputnik.

    • Ritz 7 years ago

      @Sputnik,

      “I always liked Milind’s writing skills when it came to his articles”

      In fact I saw you mentioned otherwise on the other forum. And dont compare – there is no match to what Milind can do. Anyways. I am not into all this. No grudges with anyone. Cool down Milind. I have my own life in real world now and I dont spend much time on online forums. NG banning was one good thing in my life. I am sure you also will be feeling the difference now in your life …as I dont see you commenting more …these online activities/comments if done in excess take control of one’s brain 🙂 isnt it?

      I have been always avoiding commenting on other topics – I mainly comment only on music threads since I joined this forum. I also request Sup to reconsider his quitting decision and start commenting. Its a pleasure to discuss with him – who knows music so well.

  27. sunil 7 years ago

    ritz,milind are same when it comes to their favourate stars.Milind said I should take help from govt mental health programme.Is this the way to talk to others.He cant take any criticism to his views.

  28. FS 7 years ago

    When you have so much of hatred against any person that means you are more concerned about him than yourself.

    • sauravjha 7 years ago

      absolutely ! i wud like to share an example here jst wen Ishq Shava songs was released more than praing srk ppl(srk fans!) were busy blasting salman !??? why?? aap fan kiske ho? if you liked/hated something stick to that film/actor why bring in other stars? That’s wat frustrating! same thng was done by salman fans when po po song released! unbelievable really.

  29. fearedsoul 7 years ago

    🙂

    Suprabh beta – vapas aa jao. I feel like singing ‘Tum Bin jaoon kahan….Tanqeed mein aake…kuch na phir chaaha kabhi…tumko chaah ke’ 😀

    I love this JTHJ song btw – very catchy and peppy.

  30. fearedsoul 7 years ago

    and Milo – you really got to chill. As much as i love to read ur stuff on movies – you are just going overboard with this SRK thing. I think you should look at an Utkal or a Satyam – they are both very biased too about their fav stars – but they never make it personal like you always seem to. Look forward to reading more stuff from you – just keep it about the movies and not about others opinions – if u can. If you stick to writing about movies – you are probably the best writer in this forum…so…

  31. sputnik 7 years ago

    As Dhamaka said the Urdu words for cure are “Shafa” and “Shifa”.

    The proverb is “Ishq aur Mushq chupaye nahi chupte” and if Shaava means celebration then also the lyrics make sense. Celebrate Ishq Celbrate Mushq Welome them. Unless Shava is some farsee or Arabic word I think it is just pronounced as shava.

  32. akr 7 years ago

    srk-kat ar so sweet couple

  33. Ritz 7 years ago

    RGV >> YRF

    This despite SRK being >>> aamir in dancing and Kat >>> Urmila in looks

    As I had already said on other threads – the failure of JTHJ is not of Gulzar or even Rahman – its clearly about the makers having upper hand. YRF didnt give both gulzar and rahman much freedom. Rahman was always restricted in Hindi because of filmmakers expectations – he didnt have the freedom like say a Mani or other tamil directors gave him….which restricted his score. But even in the cinematography and choreography….it restricted him….

    I know its not fair to compare songs of two eras …but I cant help comparing these two songs…

    a) Both had average songs
    b) Both didnt click with audience from beginning
    c) Both were famous after the video / film was released ….but look at the difference here…..RGV clearly excels YRF in imagination/cinematography.

    • sputnik 7 years ago

      Disagree that Rangeela songs did not click with audience from beginning.

      I remember listening to Rangeela songs on a audio cassette which my friend bought as soon the audio cassettes released. On the first listen itslelf I liked Rangeela Re, Tanha Tanha and Kya Kare Na Kare. When I heard Rangeela Re I knew the song would be a big hit and I thought Asha would win female playback singer award that year. I did not know then that Asha had withdrawn from Filmfare Awards. Asha did win a Special Award for Rangeela that year. I also thought that Rahman will win Best Music that year and he did.

      I liked Mangta Hai’s music and Shweta Shetty’s singing but did not like Rahman’s singing in it. I always thought it could have been choreographed better. Parts of it have very good choreography and parts of it don’t. I don’t like the whole vfx used in it – it reminds me of some graphics I saw in a wedding video. Urmila is a excellent dancer and Katrina is no comparison to her.

      Hai Rama was very different and it was helped by the picturization. Yaaron Sunlon was ok. I never liked Pyar Ye Jaane Kaisa Hai.

      • Baba Ji 7 years ago

        katrina dances like a stripper. it has something to do with her past.

        • Ritz 7 years ago

          Katrina doesn’t dance like a stripper. As far as I know – Strippers do have moves.

          Katrina wasted the ETT song and possibly it cud have been a best belly dance song of BW. She has wasted many songs picturized on her – she just doesnt have moves…what is she doing in Ishq Shava for example at 0:10 to 0:16 .

          In case strippers do dance so lame then I am glad I havent seen any such performance live.

          Only exception is SIK pink dress song where she seems to be having fun….she is not concious.

          • Baba Ji 7 years ago

            yes strippers can do a lot of skilful moves especially on the poles etc. I was saying she always does that pelvic moves like them .you can call her an intern-stripper 😀

      • Ritz 7 years ago

        “Urmila is a excellent dancer and Katrina is no comparison to her.”

        Completely agree. I think Urmila like dancer/performer is missing in films in these days. Not only the moves but she had the right expressions. Be it Chamma Chamma or Hai Rama – no other actress of today can show such intensity plus dance moves.

        Agree on the songs which were appealing on first listen – like Rangeela Re, Tanha Tanha and Kya kare…but this “Mangta hai kya” became popular only after the film was released.
        Agree on bad vfx also on the song but I feel that imagination is lacking in Ishq Shava and I was expecting that when I heard the song.

        “Hai Rama was very different and it was helped by the picturization. Yaaron Sunlon was ok. I never liked Pyar Ye Jaane Kaisa Hai.”

        Hai Rama I liked for the way its sung plus picturization. Urmila was too good. I liked the Puriya Dhanashree classical base which Rahman used for the song in a modern way.

        Pyaar ye jaane kaisa hai – was a typical lame song by rahman. (He has such songs by hundreds and ppl think they are melodious but I dont get it )

  34. Shinji 7 years ago

    Some interesting comments

  35. Baba Ji 7 years ago

    Still searching for full blu ray video of this ,philhaal making se kaam chalao:

Leave a reply

Log in with your credentials

or    

Forgot your details?

Create Account